List of My Babysitter's a Vampire episodes

When Ethan has trouble trying to ask Sarah on a date, Benny makes a love potion that makes both Erica and Sarah fall in love with them. However, when Benny accidentally drops the potion, the potion's scent drifts, affecting every girl in school. Benny's grandmother finds out about it and explains that because of nature's balance, all the girls who had loved them will hate them even more. As per her word, the girls arrive with weapons, crazed to kill them. Ethan and Benny lock themselves in the "Eternity Cage", a prop Ethan had ordered from a movie, to keep themselves safe and wait it out until the potion wears off; they end up spending the night in the cage.After the curse wears off Sarah and Erica, the ups truck arrives and delivers the key to the cage. The girls refuse to let the boys out until they have revenge. Ethan and Benny end up doing chores for Grandma, Sarah, and Erica.

A delivery error causes a coffee to turn its drinkers into zombies. The principal of White Chapel High has a whole case delivered for the teachers and all the teachers turn into zombies. Sarah, Ethan and Benny split up to find a cure. Benny is bitten but remains normal long enough to escape to the chemistry lab with Ethan. After inspecting the coffee's molecules, Ethan determines that the zombies are averse to cold temperatures. They decide to blast the air conditioning to subdue the zombies. In the A/C control room, Sarah is attacked by a zombified Rory. She slams him against the A/C switch, causing the A/C to turn on. The zombies become normal again.

On the night Sarah is to babysit Jane with Ethan and Benny, Rory accidentally ruins the cable, leaving the 5 of them bored. They find a board game that allows its players to talk to spirits. Sarah decides not to play and goes upstairs with Jane. Ethan reads the rules of the game, and he, Benny and Rory talk to a friendly spirit. After dismissing it, Rory plays alone and breaks the rules of the game, causing a demon spirit to unleash. The demon possesses Sarah and wreaks havoc in the house. The boys dig up the Cubile Animus and successfully suck the demon out of Sarah, just before Ethan's parents come home. However, all is not well when, unknown to the boys, a hand pokes out from the spot where they dug up the box, implying that Jesse has awakened from his grave.

After Ethan, Benny, and Sarah boast about being able to handle their adventures on their own, they each wake up alone, trapped in separate dimensions where they must face their own fears. Sarah's fear is becoming an evil, bloodthirsty vampire, Benny's is a psychotic dentist robot from a scary movie, and Ethan is chased by a cloaked figure. The three find a way to come together, and escape with Erica's help. Benny's grandma reveals that she was the one who put them in their own universe to show them they needed each other. However, Ethan was supposed to be alone in his dimension, as his fear is losing his friends; Benny's grandma had not summoned any cloaked creature. She theorizes that this means danger is coming.

One of the elders in the vampire council is attacked by the cloaked stranger from Independence Daze and Ethan is dragged to their compound to read the elder, discovering the Attacker is after the Lucifractor, something even Anastasia fears. When Sarah shows up to check to see if Ethan is all right and Due to a bet with Benny, Ethan asks Sarah on a date (nearly at the end of their one year bet limit) to which she said yes for, but when Sarah wears Jesse's bracelet Ethan has a vision of Jesse. While Ethan and Sarah attend dinner in a vampire managed restaurant with Erica as their host, Benny and Rory use a grid Ethan sees on the Cloak of the Attacker and information about the "Oh No Zone", from Ross Morgan (Ethan's Father) to discover the location of the Lucifractor, where they get the Orb and have a run in with Jesse's "bodyguard" and the Cloaked Attacker. At the Dinner Ethan confess to Sarah about seeing Jesse, only to get dragged into a telepathic link with the vampire who tells Ethan the location and purpose of the Lucifractor: To drain away dark energy, including what is needed to keep vampires alive. After Rory nearly collapses from touching the Lucifractor, Benny drags him and the Orb to the restaurant while they are being chased by the keeper of the Lucifractor. Ethan uses the Lucifractor to suck in keeper and knocks down all the vampires in the restaurant. He brings it to school the next day to "babysit" it but after an argument with Benny the weapon is taken by the Vice Principal Stern, who places it in a box with the same symbol as the one in the cloaked man's cloak.

The Vampire council summons Ethan and Benny and threaten to raid the school if they don't retrieve the Lucifractor in 24 hours. They find many of their confiscated magic items in Stern's office but are caught and given detention before they can find the Lucifractor. Sarah overhears Ethan's failed attempts and mistakes it for his opinion about their date. He agrees that it was awful which upsets Sarah who then doesn't want to speak to him when he asks for her help with the Lucifractor. He consults with Benny who reveals that he snagged the projection ring from Stern's office which will allow him to impersonate Stern and get into his office with no trouble. Unfortunately the real Stern is waiting for him and takes the ring before forcing Benny to reveal their mission as well as the fact that he is a wizard and Ethan is a seer. Ethan finds Benny in Stern's office who tells them the Lucifractor isn't there and there's a letter for him to read. The letter triggers a vision where Stern tells him that he plans to use the Lucifractor to take back Whitechapel from the vampires who stole both from his family. After Ethan comes to he tells Benny what he saw and has no idea how to stop him, to which Benny smiles and takes off the ring revealing himself as Stern. Ethan stumbles out and bumps into Sarah who appears to him as dead which causes him to run away. Later the real Benny goes to his house to check on him, and Ethan tells him what happened, and that everyone (from his point of view) is dead. Grandma tells Ethan and Sarah that regardless of what teenage nonsense is going on that they care about each other and that Sarah is the one Ethan wants to protect the most. Grandma says that Stern put a spell on Ethan so he couldn't try to stop him. When she picks up the letter Stern's spell affected her badly. When Ethan grabs her arm he enters her mind, she tells him his powers are getting stronger and he can win if he finds something stronger than fear. Afterward Grandma is catatonic on the couch and Ethan curls up terrified. Meanwhile the Vampire Council has found out about the threat and are leaving town. Erica and Rory want stay behind and fight with their friends but Anastasia enchants them, forcing them to leave with her. Back at Ethan's house Benny and Sarah finally get Ethan to snap out of it. He tells them he found something stronger than fear and holds their hands which ends the fear-binding spell. Benny and Sarah are angry when Jesse shows up at Ethan's request but he says that Jesse is their best hope. Jesse explains that he took down Stern's power hungry ancestor by letting him kill some of his flock before sneaking up on him and "draining him dry". At the Vampire Council building they run into Stern who puts Benny under a spell, causing him to attack them. Jesse wants to kill Benny and move on but Ethan plays a Magic Spell App that Benny sent to his phone which ends the enchantment. They enter the main chamber where Ethan sneaks up on Stern at the caller and enters his mind to tell him he's weak and he can't handle all the lucifractor has to offer. Incenced, Stern begins absorbing all the power and the group runs away. Outside of town, Erica and Rory watch the huge explosion before flying off. It is unknown if Sarah, Ethan, Benny, and Jesse survived the explosion.

Vanessa Morgan and Kate Todd sing the theme song for this episode.