Popcorn Sutton

Marvin "Popcorn" Sutton (October 5, 1946 – March 16, 2009) was an American Appalachian moonshiner who was born in Maggie Valley, North Carolina^[2] and was raised, lived and died in the rural areas around Maggie Valley and nearby Cocke County, Tennessee.^[3][5][6] He wrote a self-published autobiographical guide to moonshining production, self-produced a home video depicting his moonshining activities, and was later the subject of several documentaries, including one that received a Regional Emmy Award.

He committed suicide in 2009 rather than report to federal prison after being convicted of offenses related to moonshining and illegal firearm possession. Since his death, a new company and associated whiskey brand have been named after him.

Moonshining career and rise to fame

Sutton had a long career making moonshine and bootlegging. Sutton said he considered moonshine production a legitimate part of his heritage, as he was Scots-Irish and descended from a long line of moonshiners.^[3] In the 1960s or 70s, Sutton was given the nickname of "Popcorn" after his frustrated attack on a bar's faulty popcorn vending machine with a pool cue.^[3][5] Before his rise to fame at around 60 years of age, he had been in trouble with the law several times, but had avoided prison sentences. He was convicted in 1974 of selling untaxed liquor^[3][7] and in 1981 and 1985 on charges of possessing controlled substances and assault with a deadly weapon, but he received only probation sentences in those cases.^[7][8]

Sutton then wrote a self-published autobiography and guide to moonshine production called Me and My Likker, and began selling copies of it in 1999 out of his junk shop in Maggie Valley.^[2][9][10] The New York Times later called it "a rambling, obscene, and often hilarious account of his life in the trade".^[2] (A woman named Ernestine Upchurch, with whom Sutton had been living in the 1990s, later said she helped write the book.^[11][12]) At around the same time, Sutton produced a home video of the same title and released it on VHS tape.

He was a short, skinny fella, who always wore his hat – that was kind of his claim to fame, his hat that he always wore. And his bib overalls – he always wore bib overalls. Even when he came to federal court, he was wearing bib overalls. He was a friendly fellow, and of course every time you would talk to him, he would say, "Ray, I’ve run my last run of moonshine, I'm not gonna do it anymore, I'm just getting too old to be doing this stuff."

— Radio reporter Ray Snader on "Popcorn" Sutton, 2009.^[13]

His first appearance in a feature film (that wasn't self-published) was in Neal Hutcheson's 2002 documentary, Mountain Talk, as one of various people of southern Appalachia featured in this film focused on the "mountain dialect" of the area.^[8][14] Sutton next appeared in another Hutcheson film that would become the cornerstone of his notoriety, called This is the Last Dam Run of Likker I'll Ever Make. Filmed and released in 2002, the film quickly became a cult classic and over time drew the attention of television producers in Boston and New York.

In 2007, a fire on Sutton's property in Parrottsville led to firefighters discovering 650 gallons of untaxed alcohol there, for which he was convicted and put on probation again by Cocke County authorities.^[7]

Sutton was featured in the 2007 documentary Hillbilly: The Real Story on The History Channel.^[5] The source footage from the 2002 documentary was also re-worked into another Hutcheson documentary, The Last One, which was released in 2008 and was broadcast on PBS. It received a 2009 Southeast Emmy Award.^[8][15][16]

In March 2008, Sutton told an undercover federal officer he had 500 gallons of moonshine in Tennessee and another 400 gallons in Maggie Valley that he was ready to sell.^[7] This led to a raid of his property by the ATF, led by Jim Cavanaugh of Waco siege notoriety,^[17][18] In January 2009, Sutton, who had used a public defender as his attorney in the case and had pleaded guilty, was sentenced to 18 months in a federal prison for illegally distilling spirits and possession of a firearm as a felon (a .38-caliber handgun).^[2][7] Sutton, 62 and recently diagnosed with cancer, asked the U.S. District Judge Ronnie Greer to allow him to serve his sentence under house arrest, and several petitions were made by others requesting that his sentence be reduced or commuted, but this time to no avail.^[17] The judge noted that Sutton was still under probation in Tennessee at the time of the federal raid, and said that putting a man on probation again after being convicted five times of various crimes would not serve the community interest.^[7] He also noted Sutton's appearances on film surrounded by firearms and demonstrating how to make illegal moonshine.^[7] He said he had considered a harsher sentence of 24 months, but had decided on 18 months after considering Sutton's age and medical condition.^[7]

Death and memorial services

Sutton committed suicide by carbon monoxide poisoning on March 16, 2009, apparently to avoid a federal prison term due to begin a few days later. His wife Pam Sutton (whom he had married about two years before his death^[10][13]) returned home from running errands and discovered her husband in his green Ford Fairmont (which was still running) at the rear of their property in Cocke County.^[19] Mrs. Sutton said, "He called it his three-jug car because he gave three jugs of liquor for it."^[3] His daughter said he had told her in advance that he would commit suicide rather than go to jail.^[20]

Sutton's body was initially interred at a family graveyard in Mount Sterling, North Carolina. However, on October 24, 2009, it was relocated to his property in Parrottsville, Tennessee, and a public memorial service was held. His body was carried to its new resting spot by horse and carriage. Sutton's memorial grew in spectacle as country music singer Hank Williams, Jr. flew in to pay his respects. A small memorial was also held for close friends and family.^[21]

A conventional grave marker was used the head of Sutton's grave, reading "Marvin Popcorn Sutton / Ex-Moonshiner / October 5, 1946 / March 16, 2009".^[22] He had also prepared a footstone in advance for his gravesite, and for years he had kept it by his front porch and had kept his casket ready in his living room.^[4] The epitaph on his footstone reads "Popcorn Said Fuck You".^[4][13][23]

Tributes and popular culture

• Sutton's long-estranged daughter Sky Sutton wrote a self-published book in 2009 entitled Daddy Moonshine: The Story of Marvin "Popcorn" Sutton (ASIN B0027MNMC2)
• Singer-songwriter Hank Williams III sings about Sutton in the song "Moonshiner's Life" on his 2010 album Rebel Within
• Some of the prior Hutcheson documentary footage of Sutton was later also used in the 2011–12 season of the Moonshiners television series produced by Discovery Channel
• A brief photographic book about Sutton was released in 2012 – Popcorn Sutton The Making and Marketing of a Hillbilly Hero, text by Tom Wilson Jester with photographs by Don Dudenbostel (72 pp., Dudenbostel Photography, March 7, 2012, ISBN 978-0615585130)
• Another Hutcheson documentary about him was released in 2014 called A Hell of a Life^[1][24][25]

Popcorn Sutton's Tennessee White Whiskey

A bottle of the namesake whiskey (c. 2013)

On November 9, 2010, Hank Williams, Jr. announced his partnership with J&M Concepts LLC and widow Pam Sutton to distill and distribute a brand of whiskey named after Sutton that was asserted to follow his legacy.^[26] Dubbed "Popcorn Sutton's Tennessee White Whiskey", it was marketed as having been produced on stills designed by Sutton using his secret family recipe and techniques Sutton entrusted to former Supercross professional Jamey Grosser of J&M Concepts.^[27] Country music stars attending the launch event included Martina McBride, Jamey Johnson, Randy Houser, Travis Tritt, Tanya Tucker, Zac Brown, Josh Thompson, Kentucky Headhunters, Little Big Town, Colt Ford, Montgomery Gentry, Jaron and the Long Road to Love and Lee Brice.^[28] According to press reports, Popcorn Sutton's Tennessee White Whiskey would be initially distributed in Tennessee and throughout the southeast. The copper stills for its production were made by Vendome Copper and Brass in Louisville, Kentucky.^[29]

On October 25, 2013, Jack Daniel's Properties, Inc. filed suit against the distiller of Popcorn Sutton's whiskey, claiming that the newly redesigned bottle, with its square shape, beveled shoulders, and white-on-black label, too closely resembled their own.^[30] The lawsuit said that the design "...is likely to cause purchasers and prospective purchasers of the product to believe mistakenly that it is a new Tennessee white whiskey product in the Jack Daniel's line." The suit asked that all current existing bottles be taken off the market and that all profits from the sales of those bottles be handed over to Jack Daniel's. The lawsuit was settled in 2014 with undisclosed terms,^[31] and as of May 2016, the Sutton brand's bottle design has been substantially changed. The brand now uses a round bottle with a light silver background color.^[32]

Popcorn Sutton Distilling is based in Newport, Tennessee, the county seat of Cocke County. Its CEO is Megan Kvamme.^[31] In March 2015, it was announced that John Lunn, who had until then been master distiller of George Dickel Tennessee whiskey since 2005, would be joining Popcorn Sutton Distilling as its new master distiller.^[31] In July 2016, it was announced Allisa Henley, long time employ and Master Distiller at George Dickel would join her former protege John Lunn at Popcorn Sutton Distilling.^[33]

References

External links

• Scripps Interactive Newspapers Group: Knoxville News Sentinel: Don Dudenbostel's gallery of Popcorn Sutton images
• Obituary Of Marvin "Popcorn" Sutton, A Tennessee Moonshiner, March 22, 2009