Battle of Mariupol (May–June 2014)

Battle of Mariupol (May–June 2014) Part of the War in Donbass Confrontation between Ukrainian forces and Mariupol residents Date 6 May – 14 June 2014 (1 month, 1 week and 1 day) Location Mariupol, Donetsk region, Ukraine Status Ukrainian victory[1] Government forces regain complete control of the city Mariupol made provisional capital of the Donetsk Oblast Belligerents  Ukraine Donetsk People's Republic Commanders and leaders Arsen Avakov S. Demidenko † (Territorial Defence Battalion deputy commander) V. Androshchuk (POW) (Mariupol chief of police) Denis Kuzmenko (POW) Units involved Armed Forces of Ukraine: Ground Forces 72nd Guards Mechanized Brigade Internal Affairs Ministry: National Guard Azov Battalion[2] Dnipro Battalion Police[3] Donbass People's Militia Defected policemen[4][5] Strength 400 (Azov Batallion) 60 militants Casualties and losses 16 servicemen killed, 1 captured[6] 24 wounded[7][8][9][10] 3 APCs destroyed,[11][12] 4 Policemen killed and 25 wounded 20-26 killed*[8][13][14] 15–34 captured[3][15][16] 1 BRDM-2 destroyed[9][17]

Ukrainian crisis Euromaidan Revolution Pro-Russian unrest Odessa clashes Kharkiv bombing Russian military intervention Crimea Timeline Simferopol Donbass Timeline Sloviansk Kramatorsk 1st Mariupol 1st Donetsk Airport Luhansk Border Base Il-76 shoot-down Zelenopillya rocket attack Donetsk, Russia Horlivka Shakhtarsk Raion Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 Ilovaisk Novosvitlivka convoy attack Novoazovsk Mariupol offensive 2nd Donetsk Airport Volnovakha bus attack Debaltseve Mariupol rocket attack Shyrokyne Marinka

During the rising unrest in Ukraine in the aftermath of the 2014 Ukrainian revolution, the city of Mariupol, in Donetsk Oblast, saw lethal skirmishes break out between Ukrainian government forces, local police, separatist militants affiliated with the Donetsk People's Republic, and civilians. Government forces withdrew from Mariupol on 9 May 2014 after heavy fighting left the city's police headquarters gutted by fire. These forces maintained checkpoints outside the city. Intervention by Metinvest steelworkers on 15 May 2014 led to the removal of barricades from the city centre, and the resumption of patrols by local police. Separatists continued to operate a headquarters in another part of the city.

Background

Mariupol is the second-largest city in the Donetsk Oblast, and has experienced sporadic unrest since March 2014. Pro-Russian and anti-government groups had first occupied the city council building on 18 March 2014.^[18] The first violent incident had occurred during the night on 16 April 2014, when about 300 pro-Russian and anti-government protesters attacked a Ukrainian military unit in Mariupol, throwing petrol bombs.^[19] Internal Affairs minister Arsen Avakov said that troops were forced to open fire, resulting in the killing of three of the attackers.^[19]

Ukrainian government forces claimed they "liberated" Mariupol city council on 24 April 2014, though this was heavily disputed by anti-government demonstrators, and a BBC report said that there was "no sign" of the army.^[20][21] The building changed hands multiple times thereafter, but was captured by the army on 8 May.^[22][23]

Events

A violent clash involving armoured personnel carriers took place at the Mariupol police headquarters on Victory Day, 9 May 2014. The Ukrainian government said it sent in the APCs in response to an attempt by militant separatists to storm the building.^[6] According to the Internal Affairs Ministry, the assault on the station involved 60 separatists armed with automatic weapons.^[6] Some local policemen reportedly helped the militants during the takeover and later clashed with Internal Troops who fired on the building with mounted heavy machine guns atop the APCs.^[4][24]

The Ukrainian government said its contingent included police, as well as an Omega unit of the National Guard.^[6] Pro-Russian protesters attempted to stop the advance, but were unsuccessful.^[25] Ukrainian security forces attacked the police headquarters in an attempt to recapture it from militants, and during the assault the building caught fire. According to Internal Affairs minister Arsen Avakov, a separatist sniper fired from the upper floors of a hospital at Ukrainian soldiers and civilians.^[7] Avakov said that the counterattack resulted in the deaths of twenty separatists, and the capture of four, while the rest dispersed.^[6][26] He referred to the separatist militants as "terrorists", and warned that "annihilation" would be Ukraine's answer to future acts of terrorism.^[26]

Video of captured APC in Mariupol

Avakov's account of what happened was contested by some Mariupol residents, who spoke shortly after the incident with reporters from The New York Times, the BBC, and The Independent.^[5][25][26] The residents (many of whom showed their Ukrainian passports to prove they were not from Russia^[26]) said that the government had attacked local police who were sympathetic to protesters.^[5][25][26] One version of events, put forward by a group of residents cited by The New York Times, was that the clash was sparked by Mariupol police rebelling against a new police chief sent by the interim government in Kiev.^[5] The BBC report included a video showing pro-Russian activists trying unsuccessfully to stop armoured vehicles from moving into the city.^[25]

After the fighting the Ukrainian forces withdrew from the city, leaving it fully under control of pro-Russian protesters. The military retained control over checkpoints surrounding the city.^[27] The Ukrainian government said that its forces withdrew "to avoid further aggravation".^[28] The troops moving out of the city shot at unarmed civilians, according to the The Guardian.^[29][30][31] Anna Neistat from Human Rights Watch stated "my preliminary findings suggest that Ukrainian units might indeed have used excessive force near the drama theater, which resulted in deaths and injuries of some unarmed people" and urged a full, thorough investigation.^[32]

One armoured personnel carrier was captured by pro-Russian protesters. After the clashes, the protesters built barricades on roads in the city centre.^[4][13] Overnight, the city administration building was set ablaze^[33] and three gun shops were looted.^[34] The next day, insurgents set alight the captured armoured vehicle, causing the ammunition inside to explode.^[11] Individuals also threw petrol bombs at the city prosecutor's office and a military building, setting them on fire.^[35] On 11 May 2014, eight polling places were set up in Mariupol for the DPR's referendum on self-rule, with queues hundreds of metres long.^[36]

Intervention of Metinvest steelworkers

Metinvest in conjunction with owners Rinat Akhmetov and Vadim Novinsky announced on 11 May 2014 that the company would be forming citywide militia groups from local steelworkers to work with police. The squads were intended to "protect civilians from looters and criminals operating in the city". Akhmetov urged the Ukrainian government to refrain from sending its forces to the city and start negotiations with the insurgents.^[36][37][38]

Standoff between locals

An agreement initiated by Metinvest was signed on 15 May by steel plant directors, police and community leaders, and a representative of the Donetsk People's Republic separatists.^[39][40] Steelworkers and security guards from Metinvest, along with local police, began joint patrols in the city of Mariupol.^[41][42] Associated Press reported that these groups forced the insurgents out of the buildings that they had been occupying.^[41] Although a DPR representative was party to the deal which led to this vacation of buildings by the insurgents,^[39][40] a local commander of those insurgents who had been occupying the building said that "someone is trying to sow discord among us, someone has signed something, but we will continue our fight", and that "everyone ran away".^[41] Steelworkers could be seen removing barricades from the city centre, and also cleaning up the burnt city administration building.^[42] By the morning of 16 May 2014, Associated Press journalists could find no trace of the insurgents in Mariupol city centre.^[41] On 16 May, however, it seemed that separatists were not banished from the city, as reporters from the Washington Post said that about a hundred pro-Russian activists gathered on the steps of the city administration building, and that the separatist flag continued to fly over it.^[43] Radio Free Europe reported on 17 May that separatist militants (unarmed, but some wearing balaclavas) were patrolling Mariupol alongside police.^[44] On 19 May 2014, CNN reporters found DPR supporters, including armed militia, running their headquarters in a suburb of Mariupol.^[45] The leader of the group, Denis Kuzmenko, told the reporters he welcomed the role of the steelworkers in the city.^[45]

Government recapture of Mariupol

On the morning of 13 June 2014, heavy fighting resumed as part of military operations in Mariupol where the Azov and Dnipro-1 Battalions retook the city and key buildings occupied by insurgents killing five militants and destroying an insurgent BRDM-2 armoured vehicle.^[17][46][47] Two soldiers were also killed^[8] and 4–11 separatists were captured.^[15][16] A military armoured personnel carrier was destroyed during the fighting.^[12] Internal Affairs minister Avakov said "All key terrorist strongholds are being brought under control".^[48]

As a result of the six-hour battle, Ukrainian forces hoisted the national flag over the insurgent headquarters in the city and said they regained a 121-kilometre (75 mi) stretch of the border with Russia.^[48][49] Immediately following the operation, Ukrainian president Petro Poroshenko instructed the chief of the Donetsk regional state administration Serhiy Taruta to temporarily move the regional capital to Mariupol.^[48] A minor incident occurred the next morning, when a convoy of border guardsmen was attacked by insurgents whilst passing Mariupol, leaving five guardsmen dead and seven wounded.^[10]

OSCE monitors visited Mariupol to assess the situation in the city on 18 August.^[50] They reported that the city was calm and secure. They spoke to a local activist who told them that "the city had become stable" in the months after the recapture of the city by government forces. According to UNHCR, there were at least 4,000 refugees from the ongoing war in the Donbass region at the time that the monitors visited the city. Unofficial statistics cited by the OSCE give the number of refugees in Mariupol as 20,000.^[50]

Casualties

There were conflicting reports regarding the number and identity of the dead with regard to the 9 May 2014 incident. Internal Affairs minister Arsen Avakov stated that the operation resulted in the death of one policeman, and about twenty people described as "terrorists".^[13] Four militants were captured and five policemen were wounded.^[3] The The Daily Telegraph reported that some locals thought that most of the between five and twenty people killed were innocent civilians.^[51] City traffic police chief Viktor Sayenko was killed in the fighting on 9 May.^[7][52][53] A Euronews report said Mariupol residents, including the priest who conducted Sayenko's funeral, were unsure how he was killed, or who was responsible.^[52] Chief of Police Valery Andruschuk was captured by pro-Russian forces. He was released on 12 May, and was found in serious condition with a brain injury, brain contusion, and broken ribs.^[54] It was confirmed later that two pro-government territorial defence battalion paramilitaries were killed as well. One of them was the deputy commander of the Dnipro Battalion, Sergey Demidenko, who was killed by sniper fire.^[7] Citing eyewitnesses, Mariupol internet publication 0629 reported that "terrorists took Demidenko's dead body and cut his ears off and gouged his eyes."^[6] Eight soldiers were also wounded in the fighting.^[7]

The Mariupol city administration declared 10 May 2014 as a day of mourning in honour of those killed in the 9 May incident.^[55] Residents placed flowers in front of the gutted police station.^[56] A large public funeral was held in Kiev on 12 May for an Azov Battalion member who was killed in the fighting.^[2]

A further violent death was reported on 25 May, when the Ukrainian government said its special police had killed a bodyguard of Mariupol DPR leader Denis Kuzmenko, while arresting Kuzmenko himself.^[14] Five separatists and two soldiers were killed during the takeover of the city by the military on 13 June 2014.^[8] Five border guards were killed and seven wounded in an ambush attack on a military convoy on 14 June 2014.^[10]

A report by Human Rights Watch said that the Ukrainian military may have used excessive force during the Battle of Mariupol.^[57]

In January 2015, Kyiv Post cited a Bellingcat citizen's investigation into the May 2014 events in Mariupol. It asserted that Ukrainian soldiers had made a decided effort to avoid firing directly at the protesters, whilst taking fire and suffering casualties themselves. According to the investigation, of the thirteen people listed killed, six were Ukrainian law enforcement officers, soldiers, or members of the Azov Battalion.^[24]

See also

• Offensive on Mariupol (September 2014)
• Offensive on Mariupol (January 2015)

References