And Then There Was One

For the Golden Girls television episode of the same title, see The Golden Girls (season 2).
Lying Eyes

DVD cover
Genre Drama
Written by Rama Laurie Stagner
Directed by David Jones
Starring Amy Madigan
Dennis Boutsikaris
Theme music composer J.A.C. Redford
Country of origin United States
Original language(s) English
Producer(s) Angela Bromstad
Julian Marks (supervising producer)
Freyda Rothstein (executive producer)
Rama Laurie Stagner (co-producer)
Roxy Ventola (co-producer)
Editor(s) Pamela Malouf
Running time 87 minutes
Original network Lifetime Television
Original release
  • March 9, 1994 (1994-03-09)
External links
[ Website]

And Then There was One is a 1994 television film starring Amy Madigan and Dennis Boutsikaris. It was directed by David Jones. The film first aired on the Lifetime Television network on March 9, 1994.[1]


The film stars Amy Madigan as Roxy Ventola, Dennis Boutsikaris as Vinnie Ventola, and Jane Daly as Lorrie. Other cast members in the film include Jennifer Hetrick as Janet, Martha Henry as Dr. Moore, and Kenneth Welsh as David Burns.[2] The film's production companies were Freyda Rothstein Productions and Hearst Entertainment Productions.[3]

Based on real events, the film follows the story of two Los Angeles-based screenwriters who had attended a fertility clinic in order to conceive a child, before HIV testing became routine. The couple's implant was successful, but the family discovered they had the AIDS virus. Vinnie Ventola died in 1991, and the baby Miranda died of the disease only a day later.[4][5] Roxy Ventola was a co-producer of And Then There was One and she remarried in 1993, to AIDS activist Matthew McGrath, before dying from AIDS on November 14, 1994.

She had become an activist herself and a successful advocate for peer counseling and peer support programs. She was president of the Board of Women at Risk, a support service for women with HIV/AIDS; a co-founding member of Women Alive, a peer group run by and for women volunteers with HIV/AIDS; a founding member of Friends for Life, a support service for heterosexuals with HIV/AIDS; and an active member of ACT UP/LA. Her play, After the Bomb, which was about a post-AIDS world, was produced in the spring of 1994, at Open Fist Theater in Los Angeles. She performed in the Michael Kerns play, "AIDS, US Women: Silent NO More."[6]

Madigan was the winner of the CableACE award for "Actress in a Movie or Miniseries" for her performance in And Then There was One.[7] In her acceptance speech she gave tribute to the Ventola family and mentioned that Roxy had since died.[6]


In America, the film was issued on DVD via Lifetime Television as part of the "The True Stories Collection" series.[8] In recent years, Fisher Klingenstein Films issued the film on Amazon Video. In the UK, the film was released on VHS and DVD. It was issued in 1997 on VHS via Odyssey as part of the "The Weepie Collection" series, whilst another Odyseey VHS edition was also issued in 2001.,[9] It was released onto DVD in July 2008 by Infinity Media.[10] It was issued as a true story double film set alongside the 2002 film Crossing the Line, starring Terry Farrell.[11]


Roxy and Vinnie Ventola are a successful television screenwriting couple, who are struggling to conceive a child. Aside from that the couple have the perfect, happy marriage. After years of fertility treatments, the couple manage to conceive a daughter, Miranda, who falls ill with what is at first believed to be the flu, and then pneumonia. However, the underlying cause is soon revealed when the couple learn that their newborn has AIDS. Soon afterward, the two parents are also diagnosed with the virus. The film follows the family as they struggle to deal with the social, spiritual and physical tolls that the disease exacts on its sufferers.[12][13]



Bernadette McCallion of Allmovie gave the film two and a half stars out of five and called the film a "heart-wrenching made-for-cable drama".

Diane Wild of DVD Verdict reviewed the film in 2005; "And Then There Was One is an unfortunately titled 1993 made-for-TV movie based on the tragic true story of television writers Vinnie and Roxy Ventola and their baby daughter Miranda, who were all diagnosed with the AIDS virus. The first 30 minutes feel rushed and beside the point, yet take up a third of the running time. The story loses its emotional effect because we don't get to know these characters as real people. Pre-diagnosis, we see a perfect marriage between two always happy and affectionate people. Post-diagnosis, we hear platitudes about God and thankfulness and overcoming adversity and prejudice, and the two take turns feeling despondent and optimistic. None of it really rings true, despite its basis in truth. The filmmakers may have thought the story was compelling enough on its own, but without the help of well-developed characters, it feels oddly jarring. The leads are fine, but some of the supporting characters — particularly the stream of doctors — are abysmal. The Ventolas' friends are played by familiar and competent actors, but the characters are unmemorable. Criticizing this well-meaning film feels like kicking a puppy - a sick puppy - but it's not a particularly entertaining hour and a half, when what should be a heart wrenching story is undermined by a script that treats its protagonists as saints instead of people. Unfortunately And Then There was One is too dated and simplistic to bring anything meaningful to the AIDS on film canon, and it doesn't manage to be a compelling drama outside of the real-life tragedy of the disease itself."[13]


  1. And Then There was One profile,; accessed December 13, 2014.
  2. And Then There was One cast credits,; accessed December 13, 2014.
  3. And Then There was One company credits,; accessed December 13, 2014.
  4. Stealing dreams: a fertility clinic scandal - Mary Dodge, Gilbert Geis - Google Books. Retrieved 2013-05-08.
  5. "Vincent Ventola bio". 1948-05-26. Retrieved 2013-05-08.
  6. 1 2 Nancy MacNeil. "A Memorial To A Friend: Roxy Ventola McGrath". Retrieved 2013-05-08.
  7. And Then There was One,; accessed December 13, 2014.
  8. "The True Stories Collection: And Then There Was One". Retrieved 2013-05-08.
  9. "And then there was one - Amy Madigan ,Kenneth Welsh/true story: Film & TV". Retrieved 2013-05-08.
  10. "And Then There Was One". Retrieved 2013-05-08.
  11. "Crossing The Line/And Then There Was One DVD: Film & TV". Retrieved 2013-05-08.
  12. "And Then There Was One (1994) - Trailers, Reviews, Synopsis, Showtimes and Cast". AllMovie. Retrieved 2013-05-08.
  13. 1 2 "DVD Verdict Review - And Then There Was One". 2005-09-30. Retrieved 2013-05-08.

External links

This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the 11/5/2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.